If you have the skill and time, I think putting a layer of acrylic will still yield a better result. It will lift the star higher and in a more consistent manner.Hmm, that looks like a good idea to me, I’m still thinking a resin pour would help, 2 or 3 mm thick to encase the leds, could use a coating of foil on the base to get reflective too.
I have a new star on order to start playing with this idea too.
I’m going to de-badge and matt black the stars on mine, might even have a look at red leds for the boot badge, although there’s no real room to play with that one.